Too much data, too little insight: what governments need to improve health outcomes

AUTHORS

Shaheryar Manzar

Visual Hero

In 2022, Dr. Azra Pechuho, Minister of Health in Sindh, Pakistan, reviewed data suggesting maternal health facilities across the province were functioning well. But that wasn‘t the reality. A single photo showed a derelict labour room – one that was reporting fifty deliveries per month. The image laid bare the gap between what was reported and what was real, and was the catalyst to launching a new independent monitoring system in Sindh.

This story is just one example of how across Africa and Asia, governments can rarely see where their money is going, or if citizens are receiving the right services. In the second part of our Adversity as a Driver series, we explore how ministries can achieve rapid progress by turning data into action.

Lesson 1: Identify blind spots

While many countries track vaccination coverage, this alone doesn‘t tell them how to increase it.

To support citizens more effectively, countries must be able to monitor if vaccinators have shown up to vaccinate citizens, and see if vaccines are still in stock. There‘s no one-size-fits-all approach. While some countries lack a structured approach to monitoring health facilities, others rely on outdated or overly complex tools that don‘t give leaders what they need. This means we don‘t know if change is happening. And it makes it harder to learn and stay accountable.

But here‘s the good news: countries can strengthen their health systems using existing resources. That‘s what Dr. Azra Pechuho, Minister of Health, did in Sindh, Pakistan. She led the launch of an independent monitoring system in 2022, deciding which indicators would be tracked, and designing a survey for data collection. Within months, independent monitors collected regular data from 1,950 health facilities across the province. Driving provincial performance reviews, this data enables 80% of labour rooms to be fully functional today, compared to just 3% before. And that was done by spending less than 0.05% of the health budget on monitoring.

Because by knowing where to look and what to act on, countries can drive meaningful change for citizens, without additional resources.

Lesson 2: Act fast and create a culture of data use

Traditional monitoring systems often fail to help managers spot blockers, but being unable to raise these issues while they still matter can be just as harmful.

Having simple, high-quality tools that track a few critical indicators in real time – like staff and medicine availability – is crucial. Instead of duplicating efforts, we work with existing frontline staff, who update checklists or surveys as part of their daily routines. This keeps costs low while generating reliable, timely data. With actionable data produced within just 2–3 hours of submission, covering 90–95% of facilities of communities, managers can spot problems early and fix them quickly.

In Sokoto, Nigeria, the government launched routine health facility monitoring in October 2024. Within months, the availability of many medicines increased across the province, showing what‘s possible with speed. Likewise, in Ethiopia, a basic smartphone app with real-time tracking abilities helped staff identify 283 broken fridges. Once repaired, these fridges enabled the delivery of 250,000 vaccine doses.

Because when it comes to collecting and using data, being simple and fast beats being complex and late.

Lesson 3: Visualise progress clearly

Too often, managers are left to rely on outdated, paper-based plans that show where teams are supposed to go, but not whether they get there, how far communities are, or if key areas get missed. This lack of visibility destroys accountability and leads to large gaps in vaccination coverage.

As Saad Rehman, Data Analyst Lead for Afghanistan and Pakistan, puts it: “Visual tools are critical to turning data into something truly actionable.”

By layering data from vaccinators who visit local communities onto digital maps, we‘ve helped local teams move from paper plans to real-time delivery tracking. In Pakistan, a dashboard maps each facility and its surrounding communities, with simple colour-coded indicators showing which areas have been reached (green) and which haven‘t (red). This shift enabled the proportion of communities being visited by a vaccinator at least once per month to increase by almost 23% from July 2024 to May 2025.

Clear visuals don‘t just show the plan – they reveal the gaps, guide the work, and drive results.

Lesson 4: Turn Insight into action

Without a structured way to review and act on insights, frontline teams lose focus, managers miss early warning signs, and communities continue to be overlooked.

That‘s why reviews must be at the heart of any data-led approach. We work with governments to establish regular reviews – ideally monthly – that bring together managers, supervisors, and frontline teams to identify real problems and agree on next steps. These sessions use data not as an end in itself, but as a tool to surface challenges and guide action.

In the DRC‘s Mashako Plan, designed to raise immunisation coverage, these kinds of structured reviews helped drive rapid improvements. The number of immunisation sessions nearly doubled from around 14,900 per month in 2018 to over 28,000 in 2021, because data was actively used to spot gaps and respond in real time.

With the right routines, data doesn‘t sit on a shelf. Instead, it fuels momentum and results.

In summary: What we‘ve learned

Improving data systems shouldn‘t be seen as a cost to the system. It makes everything else work faster and more efficiently.

Ensuring better data use is about:

Because data is the information that leads to lasting change.

For more on driving change for citizens without big spending, see what our Head of Partnerships, Ahmed Razzak, says about building political commitment.

Related Insights

How Zamfara overcame the odds to boost child immunisation
How Zamfara overcame the odds to boost child immunisation

September 30, 2026

3 min read

Delivering vaccines in Nigeria’s Zamfara State means racing against both time and terrain. When seasonal rains turn dirt roads into rivers, or securit…

Read more

How Sokoto is transforming routine immunisation from the ground up
How Sokoto is transforming routine immunisation from the ground up

August 19, 2026

3 min read

Understanding why routine vaccination stalled in northern Nigeria requires a look at what happens on the back roads of Sokoto. Failure is rarely a cas…

Read more

Facing the uncomfortable truth for mothers in Nigeria
Facing the uncomfortable truth for mothers in Nigeria

April 9, 2026

3 min read

In late 2025, a senior health official in Sokoto was shown a series of photos from a local health clinic. He saw a rusted delivery bed and a room with…

Read more

When being near a clinic isn’t enough
When being near a clinic isn’t enough

March 10, 2026

3 min read

In July 2025, a senior public health leader in Kano, Nigeria, sat before a screen flashing red. The data revealed an uncomfortable truth: two urban ar…

Read more

Hidden in plain sight: reaching zero-dose children in the DRC
Hidden in plain sight: reaching zero-dose children in the DRC

February 23, 2026

3 min read

In a remote village in the DRC, I recently slept in a health centre 200 km from any urban hub. My goal was to see what was really happening on the gro…

Read more

Reaching children living with HIV in Nigeria
Reaching children living with HIV in Nigeria

February 3, 2026

4 min read

Children and adolescents living with HIV in Nigeria face a six- to eight-fold higher risk of developing cervical cancer. Protecting them against HPV –…

Read more

How Sindh turned urgency into better maternal care
How Sindh turned urgency into better maternal care

November 24, 2025

4 min read

When we began working with the Government of Sindh on maternal and newborn health, the challenges were daunting – overstretched facilities, unreliable…

Read more

Punjab’s health revolution: how simple fixes saved thousands of lives
Punjab’s health revolution: how simple fixes saved thousands of lives

November 13, 2025

4 min read

When we began work in Punjab, Pakistan in 2014, one in eleven children died before their fifth birthday – far worse than in Punjab, India, where focus…

Read more

Turning AI into action for women’s and children’s health
Turning AI into action for women’s and children’s health

October 17, 2025

4 min read

Every day across Africa, women and children die from causes we already know how to prevent. The real challenge is not lack of innovation, but connecti…

Read more

The best innovation isn’t always tech. Often, it’s human.
The best innovation isn’t always tech. Often, it’s human.

August 28, 2025

2 min read

It makes sense to associate innovation with technology. But in the toughest settings, the most creative solutions are those that empower, recognise, a…

Read more

Reaching children in security-compromised areas of Nigeria
Reaching children in security-compromised areas of Nigeria

August 20, 2025

3 min read

Last month in Zamfara, Nigeria, a vaccinator prepared to visit a remote village, where most children had never received a single vaccine. Local contac…

Read more

Cultivating effective delivery
Cultivating effective delivery

August 13, 2025

2 min read

At its heart, delivery refers to a set of approaches, tools, and guidelines used to help governments improve services for citizens. It’s about moving…

Read more

Doing big things, fast: how scaling with urgency drives breakthroughs
Doing big things, fast: how scaling with urgency drives breakthroughs

July 18, 2025

3 min read

In March 2020, the world locked down overnight. No pilots. No randomised controlled trials. Just bold action in the face of uncertainty. Because the s…

Read more

Delivery is a skill. And it can be learned.
Delivery is a skill. And it can be learned.

July 10, 2025

3 min read

In March 2024, Ethiopia launched its first single-dose HPV vaccine campaign. This was a huge first step for preventing cervical cancer in the country.…

Read more

What adversity teaches us about innovation
What adversity teaches us about innovation

June 17, 2025

2 min read

Over the past decade, innovative, tech-enabled tools have become critical in enabling governments across Africa to address vital public sector challen…

Read more

Building political commitment to deliver, sustain and scale change
Building political commitment to deliver, sustain and scale change

June 6, 2025

4 min read

Adversity doesn’t stop leaders. It reveals them. When systems are strained and budgets tight, political commitment makes the difference between well-i…

Read more

How fuel cards are helping Pakistan’s vaccinators go further
How fuel cards are helping Pakistan’s vaccinators go further

April 29, 2025

2 min read

Low immunisation coverage in low- and middle-income countries is often the result of limited outreach vaccination capabilities. Often needed for the m…

Read more

Immunisation for all is humanly possible
Immunisation for all is humanly possible

April 24, 2025

2 min read

As we mark World Immunization Week 2025, this year’s banner, Immunization for All is Humanly Possible, isn’t just a rallying cry. It’s a global commit…

Read more

Healthy beginnings, hopeful futures
Healthy beginnings, hopeful futures

April 7, 2025

3 min read

On World Health Day 2025, the theme is healthy beginnings, hopeful futures. In light of increasing development sector spending cuts, Susan Mackay – He…

Read more

Vaccinating hard-to-reach communities in the DRC
Vaccinating hard-to-reach communities in the DRC

February 28, 2025

3 min read

Vaccination coverage is growing in low- and middle-income countries, yet some communities are being missed entirely. Many communities across low- and…

Read more

Combining rapid coverage assessments with demand surveys
Combining rapid coverage assessments with demand surveys

February 27, 2025

3 min read

Gathering data on low immunisation communities is an important first step to increasing vaccination coverage for citizens. Once immunisation coverage…

Read more

Supporting citizens through flooding crises
Supporting citizens through flooding crises

August 20, 2024

2 min read

Citizens often face a wide variety of problems during flooding crises, but strong support from governments, NGOs and partners can overcome these chall…

Read more

Improving labour services in low- and middle-income countries
Improving labour services in low- and middle-income countries

August 19, 2024

2 min read

Labour services have not always been up to the standards needed for expectant mothers, but significant improvements are being made in low- and middle-…

Read more

How to increase measles vaccination coverage globally
How to increase measles vaccination coverage globally

July 29, 2024

3 min read

Measles vaccines are estimated to have averted around 57 million deaths globally between 2000 and 2022. However, there is still work to be done, with…

Read more

How AI can support education systems
How AI can support education systems

July 25, 2024

2 min read

Using AI for the benefit of education systems remains a challenge. But if done correctly, there can be significant benefits. AI has been one of the mo…

Read more

Solutions to deliver more HPV vaccines to girls
Solutions to deliver more HPV vaccines to girls

July 11, 2024

2 min read

Even where the demand for HPV vaccines is high, opportunities are being missed to vaccinate girls. But there are ways to ensure girls receive the vacc…

Read more

Using technology to improve education
Using technology to improve education

July 11, 2024

2 min read

There are limits to how technology can be used in education. Nevertheless, technology is being used to create improvements across low- and middle-inco…

Read more

Increasing the demand for HPV vaccines
Increasing the demand for HPV vaccines

July 10, 2024

2 min read

Only one in eight girls globally are vaccinated against HPV. There are various ways to raise the demand. A single vaccination can protect girls a…

Read more

Increasing investment in primary education
Increasing investment in primary education

July 10, 2024

3 min read

Investment in primary education is falling short of targets in many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). But there are proven strategies to turn…

Read more

Using technology to support frontline health workers
Using technology to support frontline health workers

June 21, 2024

2 min read

Some health workers understandably worry about technology further overburdening them. But if interventions are designed correctly, more overburdening…

Read more

Improving immunisation coverage through health worker accountability
Improving immunisation coverage through health worker accountability

June 17, 2024

2 min read

The vast majority of frontline staff work exceptionally hard. But governments require evidence of performance to address concerns. Accountability is i…

Read more

Giving frontline health workers a stronger voice
Giving frontline health workers a stronger voice

June 14, 2024

2 min read

Some of the world’s best organisations are seeing positive change by letting frontline workers take the lead in suggesting and creating solutions. Und…

Read more

Why incremental improvements are the pathway to change
Why incremental improvements are the pathway to change

June 11, 2024

2 min read

Governments and donors often want to address major health and education issues with one large policy adjustment. But it is the small, daily, improveme…

Read more

Delivering sustainability in low- and middle-income countries
Delivering sustainability in low- and middle-income countries

June 10, 2024

3 min read

Many people agree that sustainability is the right path to follow, but delivering it is something else entirely. Sustainability is an important goal i…

Read more

Reaching 20 million children in two weeks: learnings from Sindh, Pakistan
Reaching 20 million children in two weeks: learnings from Sindh, Pakistan

March 9, 2023

3 min read

The province of Sindh in Pakistan ran one of the largest Measles-Rubella (MR) vaccination campaigns, reaching around 20 million children in two weeks.…

Read more

My new table: a first week at Acasus
My new table: a first week at Acasus

December 5, 2022

2 min read

Sue advises Acasus on technical issues in the health sector. September 14  Our founder, Fenton Whelan, invited me to an all-staff meeting in Duba…

Read more

Increasing demand for immunisation
Increasing demand for immunisation

December 2, 2022

3 min read

Hesitancy around vaccination is a growing challenge across the world. Our most recent data from Africa shows 72% of individuals expressing hesitation…

Read more

What routine immunisation can learn from mass vaccination campaigns
What routine immunisation can learn from mass vaccination campaigns

August 4, 2022

2 min read

Immunisation coverage in Balochistan stands at 38%, the lowest in Pakistan. The province faces unique challenges in increasing routine immunisation; i…

Read more

Lessons learned: rebuilding health service delivery after conflict
Lessons learned: rebuilding health service delivery after conflict

July 5, 2022

2 min read

Northern regions in Ethiopia have been operating with reduced or disrupted health services. We supported regional administration and the government in…

Read more

Rapidly mapping health facilities in fragile and conflict-affected contexts
Rapidly mapping health facilities in fragile and conflict-affected contexts

May 26, 2022

3 min read

Somalia is one of the most difficult places to provide health services, following decades of conflict and political instability, and persistent limita…

Read more

What made Mozambique’s Covid vaccination drive so successful?
What made Mozambique’s Covid vaccination drive so successful?

May 10, 2022

3 min read

Mozambique’s strong performance is gaining recognition regionally and internationally, despite initial constraints of vaccine supply, in-country deliv…

Read more

Making data work for governments
Making data work for governments

April 5, 2022

2 min read

We summarise four challenges below and mention some of the best practices that can help partners and implementers overcome them. Reliance on self-repo…

Read more

Practical advice for young public officials
Practical advice for young public officials

February 22, 2022

2 min read

Here are a few insights I gained from my experience that I would like to share with the thousands of young public officials who have to make decisions…

Read more

From evidence to action in education
From evidence to action in education

November 23, 2021

3 min read

Around 90% of children in sub-Saharan Africa cannot read a basic sentence by the time they turn ten. Often this is due to the poor use of evidence in…

Read more

Using geospatial analysis to improve health service delivery
Using geospatial analysis to improve health service delivery

August 31, 2021

3 min read

Each year, around 10 million children receive no vaccinations at all. More than fifty percent of these zero-dose children live in urban slums, remote…

Read more

The gender gap in Covid-19 vaccination – and what to do about it
The gender gap in Covid-19 vaccination – and what to do about it

August 10, 2021

2 min read

A few weeks ago, Taimur Khan Jhagra, Health Minister and Finance Minister in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan, used his Twitter account to highlight gende…

Read more

Mitigating learning losses after Covid-19
Mitigating learning losses after Covid-19

June 8, 2021

2 min read

Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, nine out of ten children in Sub-Saharan Africa were unable to read and understand a simple text by the age of ten.…

Read more

Mapping and understanding the needs of populations in urban slums
Mapping and understanding the needs of populations in urban slums

May 12, 2021

3 min read

It can be challenging to provide consistent health services in urban slums, which often contain populations with some of the lowest levels of access t…

Read more

Making the Covid-19 vaccine rollout work
Making the Covid-19 vaccine rollout work

May 11, 2021

3 min read

The rollout of the Covid vaccine is unlike any other. For most public officials involved, it will be the most complex challenge they will ever face in…

Read more

How simple digital tools are improving immunisation in Mozambique
How simple digital tools are improving immunisation in Mozambique

May 10, 2021

3 min read

To help reduce the rate of under-immunised children in Mozambique, the government launched new digital supervision tools to help manage service delive…

Read more

How satellite data is helping vaccinators reach missed communities in the DRC
How satellite data is helping vaccinators reach missed communities in the DRC

April 6, 2021

3 min read

In 2017, surveys showed that only one in three children were fully immunised in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), while one in five did not…

Read more

Simplifying vaccine delivery in Chad
Simplifying vaccine delivery in Chad

February 23, 2021

3 min read

One of the first steps in redesigning a vaccine distribution system is to understand the existing bottlenecks, flaws and inefficiencies that prevent i…

Read more

The science of detecting false data
The science of detecting false data

November 19, 2019

2 min read

Leaders of health and education systems often rely on datasets that are inaccurate or incomplete. Advanced analytics can help understand and improve d…

Read more